what the main different between nat- mur and carcinogen? | Homeopathy Discussion Forums

Ask Questions about Health, Homeopathy, Medicine – Get Answers from Experts and Peers!


Please consider registering

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —

— Match —

— Forum Options —

Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed sp_TopicIcon
what the main different between nat- mur and carcinogen?
No permission to create posts
Topic Rating: 0 Topic Rating: 0 (0 votes) 
January 21, 2016
9:38 am
New Member
Forum Posts: 1
Member Since:
January 21, 2016
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

How do I decide which one to give in a case which fit them both? 

March 10, 2016
8:32 am
Pankaj Titar
Bandra [Mumbai]


Hpathy Team
Forum Posts: 7
Member Since:
February 14, 2014
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

hello Avshatid ,


I may not be big enough to teach ,but I can assure you that i can help you and me to learn together on this topic..


I suppose by ‘carcinogen’ you meant carcinosin , If i got you wrong please correct me and I can correct myself..


In 1996 journal of new england homoeopathy [the date might be wrong but it is between 1996-1998] Frank Grubber MD had written an article on carcinosin which takes inspiration from the system of ”phases” developed by Paul Herscu , I will try to squeeze the entire matter through my memory and make it short.


The Cycle of Carcinosin


and when it comes to nat-mur, chicago lectures by kent puts the remedy perfectly as followed

There is a long chain of mental symptoms; hysterical condition of the mind and body; weeping alternating with laughing; irresistible laughing at unsuitable times; prolonged, spasmodic laughter.

This will be followed by tearfulness, great sadness, joylessness. No matter how cheering the circumstances are she cannot bring herself into the state of being joyful. She is benumbed to impressions, easily takes on grief, grieves over nothing.

Unpleasant occurrences are recalled that she may grieve over them. Consolation aggravated the state of the mind – the melancholy, the tearfulness, sometimes brings on anger. She appears to bid for sympathy and is mad when it is given.

Headache comes on with this melancholy. She walks the floor in rage. She is extremely forgetful; cannot cast up accounts; is unable to meditate; forges what she was going to say; loses the thread of what she is hearing or reading. There is a great prostration of the mind.

Unrequited affection brings on complaints. She is unable to control her affections and falls in love with a married man. She knows that it is foolish, but lies awake with love for him. She falls in love with a coachman. She knows that she is unwise, but cannot help it. In cases of this kind Natr. mur. will turn her mind into order, and she will look back and wonder why she was so silly.


also note down that natmur has strong aversion to fatty and rich foods especially bread.

I hope this helps you to understand or come up with more doubts which will benefit you and me in the process of learning 🙂


Forum Timezone: UTC 5.5

Most Users Ever Online: 231

Currently Online:
9 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

David Kempson: 775

drofart: 769

Manish Bhatia: 667

in need of help2: 373

Firuzi Mehta: 335

In need of help: 308

inquisitivegirl: 196

Elaine Lewis: 180

patti: 177

Surabhi Sharma: 164

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 27

Members: 4387

Moderators: 6

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4

Forums: 17

Topics: 1557

Posts: 9080

Newest Members:

jamesannie, Angel White, ritatono, swati28, Dr. Devina, Paola Meli, huaioejd25, Kelli Revoir, Neerja Kapoor, veggielover

Moderators: Alan V. Schmukler: 992, Rochelle: 200, David A. Johnson: 38, John: 18, Shirley Reischman: 193, Pankaj Titar: 7

Administrators: Manish Bhatia: 0, Hpathy.com: 0